
Digital KOnflict

Our Items
Our 10 items have been selected in order to provide a broad overview on this phenomenon in the context of the Ukrainian invasion.
They span from textual items published by universities, to physical artworks preserved or purchased in museums, to digital images or multimedia items that can be found in memes, gifs or video digital archives.
As such, our items both fall within and go beyond LAM heritage (that is: Libraries, Archives and Museums), with some of our items being first discovered on social media platforms such as Twitter, YouTube or Telegram.
Through our items, we wanted to reflect on the different propaganda strategies and media orientations of both sides of the conflict.
Thus, we selected items that were produced in a ‘grass-root’ (or bottom-up) fashion, and items, digital or analogic, that were produced, ordered, or diffused by the Russian or Ukrainian authorities.
We observed, as a general tendency, that the Ukrainian side favors more digital forms of propaganda while the Russian one, more analogic ones (for instance, through national TV broadcast). We believe that it might be the case because the former attempts to attract international support, whereas the latter tries to preserve internal support from its population – as well as control – for the ongoing invasion narrative.
We tried to express this tendency through our items, though we raised some exceptions:
-
We chose the massively diffused video “Anti-war protester interrupts Russian State TV news broadcast”, dating back to march 2022, and a poster dating back to 1968 – respectively being produced in and depicting Moscow – to represent Russia’s attachment to analogic and more controllable forms of propaganda imagery, though we also included a gif multimedia item depicting Vladimir Putin crossing a river on a bear, as a digital form of propaganda.
-
For the Ukrainian side of the informational battle, we preferred two memes digital items – the ones that were of our original interest for the project – though one was produced and diffused by the non-governmental grass-root Twitter account ‘Ukrainian Memes Force’, and the other, by the Twitter account of the Ukrainian government itself, which illustrates the political power of memes and their ability to go beyond grass-root digital practices.
Digital propaganda in the Ukrainian invasion context can also be better understood through the ‘Social media and visual framing of the conflict in Eastern Ukraine’ article published in 2017, and because it involves a lot of memes digital objects, can be instructed by the foregrounding books of The Selfish Gene, for its conceptual origins, and Memes in Digital Culture, for its political impact and practices.
Diving into the specific event of the 2022 Ukrainian invasion by Russia – but drawing from ancestral historical figures of Ukraine – we chose the digital image of Saint Javelin, which has acquired a strong international symbolic power of the local resistance (used for instance in stickers and merchandise in support of Ukraine) as well as a 1901 painting of Saint Olga of Kiev, which became a symbol of strength and courage for the Ukrainian people.
digital image
Types of Headaches

“Types of headaches” is a meme published by the official Twitter account of the Ukranian government itself in December 2021.
Based on a well known humorous meme template delineating the three areas affected by headache types, but hijacking it in its descriptions, with Russia being described as the largest brain area affected by the illness.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
physical artwork
Saint Olga of Kiev

Saint Olga of Kiev was a regent of Kievan Rus' region, from 945 to 960. She is today recognized as one of Eastern Orthodoxy’s greatest saints. She is known for her subjugation of the Drevlians, a tribe that had killed her husband Igor of Kiev.
Because of her efforts, she quickly became a symbol of strength and fortitude for the Ukrainian people.
To represent her we chose a portrait made by Bruni Nikolai Alexandrovich, currently held at the State Russian Museum.
With her, in the context of the Russian invasion, the population found a special medieval role model, who personifies their bravery in the face of hardship.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
multimedia
Putin Bear: Vladimir Putin Crossing River

"Putin Bear GIF” is a GIF produced on imgflip.com by an anonymous user called “ersin45”, stored on the Tenor gif digital archive.
The GIF depicts Russian president Vladimir Putin vigorously and bare chest riding a bear while crossing a river.
The GIF has been used and identified in a Telegram channel of radical Putin supporters, sharing in their group ‘thread’ some types of propaganda narratives and imagery about the invasion in Ukraine.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
text
Social Media and Visual Framing of the conflict in Eastern Ukraine

This 2017 article investigates the use of social media and visual framing as a visual background of the conflict in Eastern Ukraine.
Using a large set of visual data from a popular Russian social media, VK, the authors use computational content analysis to examine how the conflict was represented and interpreted both in pro-Ukrainian and pro-Russian online communities, during the peak of violence of summer 2014.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
text
Memes in Digital Culture

Published in 2013 and written by professor Limor Shifman of the Univeristy of Jerusalem, this book is one of the most well-known examples of digital culture analysis.
The author discusses a series of internet-culture objects (above all, memes) investigating their overall impact and proposing memes as new modes of political participation, agents of globalization and forms of grassroots popular imaginary builders.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
multimedia
“Anti-war protester interrupts Russian State TV”

Originally broadcasted by the State TV ‘Channel One Russia’ on the 15th of March 2022, this video archive of the British ‘Channel 4 News’ broadcast published on Youtube and archive.org represents an icon of Russian counter-propaganda in the Ukraine invasion context, which became viral worldwide.
A few weeks after the beginning of the invasion, Russian TV journalist Marina Ovsyannikova interrupts the live broadcast of her TV channel with a poster “NO WAR”, in english, and below it (in Russian), “don’t believe the propaganda. They’re lying to you here”. Just before interrupting the broadcast, the journalist shared a video on Twitter explaining the intentions behind her action.
Our item is a commentary in English by the British channel of this live action, that stunned the world and illustrated a tension between governmental propaganda by the Russian government and citizen tentatives of counter-propaganda, on national media as well as on social media.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
physical artwork
"ГОРОДУ ГЕРОЮ МОСКВЕ" [CITY HERO MOSCOW

This Soviet propaganda poster was issued in 1968, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the October Revolution.
It depicts Moscow with typical USSR icons (red stars and communist imagery, as well as the Aurora ship). It is a clear example of analog and 20th century mediatic forms of propaganda.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
digital image
I’m Doing my Part

“I’m doing my part” is a meme taken as a snapshot from the 1997 American movie ‘Starship Troopers’.
The meme was widely used in a wide array of contexts, throughout the 2010s and early 2020s, but most usually appears to represent the pride for the support given to online social movements (likes, retweets, donations…).
Ukrainian Memes Forces, a non-governmental Twitter account launched in February 2022, shared this meme to celebrate the event of having reached more than a hundred thousand followers.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
digital image
Saint Javelin

Used as a symbol for stickers and merchandise, this digital image raised more than a million dollars for a charity campaign in support of Ukraine, in 2022, thanks to its website saintjavelin.com.
Saint Javelin is described as a “concept” or “resistance”, meme from its Wikipedia entry’s description.
Based on a 2012 US painting called “Madonna Kalashnikov”, this Saint Javelin image alters it by portraying Mary holding an anti-tank weapon (commonly known as “Javelin”), sent in large quantities by Western allies to Ukrainian forces.
Saint Javelin is described as a “concept” or “resistance”, meme from its Wikipedia entry’s description.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.
text
The Selfish Gene

Written by the American author Richard Dawkins, The Selfish Gene is a milestone for its sociological analysis and starting from an evolutionary biology metaphor.
This book dates back to 1976 and coined the word and concept of “meme”, marking the start of the cultural studies branch of ‘Memetics’. For the evolutionary biologist, memes can be defined as small bits of culture that act as if they were individual genes. Each artifact carries with it a piece of the culture in which it was created and each gene (or meme), combined together, becomes part of a larger genome (like the DNA) which symbolically represents a social consciousness of a certain culture.
Futura Light è un carattere molto gettonato, che si ispira agli elementi del design Bauhaus. Ideale per intestazioni, banner, loghi e molto altro perché fa risaltare le parole.